NOT A PERFORMANCE - A CRY FOR HELP: THE REALITY OF BEGGING BEHIND THE MASK

  • Muthiah Karupaya
  • Amira Najwafitri Amir Arif
Keywords: Child begging, exploitation, anonymity, Child Act 2001, poverty

Abstract

The growing trend of costumed begging in Malaysia, particularly involving children wearing full-body costumes such as frog suits, has become increasingly visible due to social media. Although begging itself is not new, this practice is often disguised as street performance, with children and accompanying adults using donation boxes or QR codes to solicit money. While similar costumes originated in China for legitimate street vending, in Malaysia they are primarily used to elicit donations. The paper argues that costumed begging is not just harmless entertainment but a form of child exploitation driven by poverty, unemployment, and lack of marketable skills. The use of costumes provides anonymity, reducing stigma for those involved while simultaneously hindering identification, public reporting, and law enforcement. Children are frequently coerced by adults, including parents or organised syndicates, and the mobility and anonymity of these activities make them attractive to groups potentially linked to trafficking networks and vulnerable populations such as undocumented migrants and refugees. Under Malaysia’s Child Act 2001 and the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the use of children for begging constitutes exploitation. Section 17(1)(k) of the Child Act 2001 classifies such children as in need of care and protection, while Section 32 criminalises forcing a child to beg. Despite these clear legal provisions, there have been no reported prosecutions under Section 32(1), revealing a critical enforcement gap. The paper calls for stronger enforcement, noting the critical enforcement gap evidenced by the complete absence of reported prosecutions under Section 32(1) of the Child Act 2001 to date, despite the visibility of costumed child begging across Malaysian streets and social media platforms.  The absence of prosecutorial action, juxtaposed against statistics by Jabatan Kebajikan Masyarakat in 2018 that reported 355 children were reported to be begging and the rescue of 67 trafficked children by the Anti-Trafficking in Persons and Anti-Smuggling of Migrants Council (MAPO) over a five-year period, a portion of whom were exploited specifically as beggars underscores the urgent need for more proactive enforcement by the relevant authorities. The paper further calls for clearer differentiation between poverty-driven cases and syndicate-controlled begging, and advocates for the treatment of organized child-begging syndicates as trafficking under the Anti-Trafficking in Persons and Anti-Smuggling of Migrants Act 2007 (ATIPSOM). This is justified on the basis that syndicate-controlled costumed begging mirrors the core elements of trafficking as defined under ATIPSOM, namely the recruitment, harbouring, and exploitation of persons particularly where accompanying adults share no familial relationship with the child. It further advocates rehabilitative and preventive measures to protect children without criminalizing poverty.

Published
2026-06-30
How to Cite
Karupaya, M., & Amira Najwafitri Amir Arif. (2026). NOT A PERFORMANCE - A CRY FOR HELP: THE REALITY OF BEGGING BEHIND THE MASK . INSAF | The Journal of the Malaysian Bar, 43(1), 1-20. Retrieved from https://insaf.malaysianbar.org.my/ojs/index.php/jmr/article/view/122
Section
Practitioner Note